In a recurring feature in this newsletter, I publish stories and court documents that you won't have seen anywhere else, ones that provide a mix of strange true crime and real world surveillance. I call it The Wire IRL.
A dark story this week, in which a man in Arizona is accused of stabbing his own grandmother more than 50 times.
From my article in Forbes today: During a police interview, the suspect said repeatedly that he’d snapped and started stabbing his grandmother for no reason, according to a search warrant. The FBI agent asked the interviewee how many times he believed he’d stabbed his grandma, to which he responded “maybe 53.” Another interviewer asked what he’d been feeling during the stabbing, to which he replied, “nothing.” When the suspect was then asked what he was feeling as he was being interviewed, the suspect said, “no remorse.”
With the interviewee providing no clear motivation for his alleged actions, the FBI are carrying out a search on the suspect’s iPhone 11, a device from which the feds have previously harvested data, even when it was locked. At the top of the list of reasons for searching the iPhone is to find any signs of an “intent, plan, or motive to kill or harm any person, his mens rea, or his mental state.” Mens rea is the awareness of wrongdoing in the act of committing a crime; in other words, criminal intent. The mental state of the accused could determine the nature and severity of the charge they face, and penalty they could receive at trial. Arizona judges can impose the death penalty for first-degree murder sentences but the state has suspended executions since 2014.
For me, this case begs the questions: How much can your phone and your data reveal about your mental health? And could the government use that against you?
I'm not publishing the suspect's name in full, but you can read the search warrant in a redacted form for yourself here.
If you have any tips on government surveillance or cybercrime, drop me an email on tbrewster@forbes.com or message me on Signal at +447837496820. |